retro.pizza is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.
A poly-fandom instance for nerds to talk about nerd culture. No Nazis, no TERFs.

Server stats:

274
active users

I'm not a trained vexillologist but I was born and raised in Illinois and all these flags suck shit.

ilsos.gov/special/IFC/10finali

The six pointed Chicago star ought to be included in an Illinois flag. 21 is too many stripes. The negative space I is clever but it doesn't work. Illinois might be a big negative space but giant serif I doesn't say "Illinois" to me (unlike the current Illinois flag, which literally says "Illinois" to everyone).

No shade to Johnna and Spresalynn but one, that's not what a monarch butterfly looks like and two, seven states have the monarch butterfly as their state insect. It's not remotely emblematic of Illinois. Also that is a bad shade of orange. Sorry.

When the guy who submitted this flag (found it? After learning about this two days ago?) repeatedly mentions that it needs work it probably doesn't deserve to be on the finalists list. I don't have to explain why complex abstract shapes are bad flag design.

I hate to admit it but this is the best flag on the list. A symbol that is both corn kernels, a gear, and the state flower? Blue stripes that abstractly represent prominent water features? It's well-thought. Shame about the colors. Miserable desaturated millennial colors, get that shit out of here. Come back with some real shades of blue.

Incredible "I just think it's neat" energy here. The star is gold because Illinois is rich! The big bar is for Lake Michigan and the little one are uhhhh they just look nice! The circle is Abraham Lincon's hat seen from above! Definitely all real things considered while making this flag and not just made up after the fact.

If you put the shape of your state on your flag you have already lost, but sure let's stick a guy's head in there too. Why not? Totally sane things to do on a flag. I like that they have a special star to signify Chicago but it's the wrong shape. Excellent eye for detail.

Listen guys we're trying to get rid of the current "super complicated picture in the middle of nothing" flag. Stop replacing it with a different complicated picture. Replacing the word "Illinois" printed on the flag with the state's outline is in no way an improvement. The light blue side bars are ugly and make the whole thing feel constrained.

This would be a great flag... for any state in the midwest. 18 star points referencing Illinois founding in 1818 borders on being an easter egg. They claim this flag has 21 stripes, where is the 21st? The white outline around the sun? That's a stripe? And what about the white, anyway? The description mentions blue, green, and yellow, but not white. I guess white is just the default color, representing how whiteness is valued in the great state of Illinois.

No. No. Fuck. Take your crayons and go home.

Mr. Encyclopedia

Much star. Very circle. Wow. This is the last flag on the list, but why are so many of these flags predominantly blue and white? What is going on that people think about Illinois, a state that is edge to edge farmland, and think blue and white? Anyway, if you changed this flag to red and black it would be the perfect flag for an evil dictatorship in a cartoon.